The Lowland Lobban STR “motif” predates surnames (rev. Dec. 2022)
Most of the Y-DNA data mentioned on this website are from the “Big Y” tests (Y-500, later Y-700), which analyze single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), the more useful for connecting family lines. But the tests from Y-37 to Y-111, which are short tandem repeat (STR) tests, also provide useful information. Jim Logan in the Clan Logan International Society has used them to work out all the “Limbs” in the Logan tree, as he explained in a seminar to the Society (recording accessible on the Society site, copy the password on the landing page ). The composition of Limbs 3 and 7 which you see on this One-Name site are Jim’s groupings, and I recently learned from our Y-DNA expert, John Sloan, that the Lowland Lobbans have a recognizable “motif” in the Y-111 STR results, i.e., a pattern of some unusual variations. The following brief explanation is based on what I understand from John and Jim. I will preface the description of the motif with a very brief primer on STRs, with the recommendation that if you want a more extensive explanation, you should watch Jim’s presentation.
The double helix structure of DNA consists of two linked strings of nucleotides, basically four: adenine, thymine, guanine and cytosine, usually just called A, T, G. and C. In the helix, A only pairs with T and C with G. In the small fragments of the 59-million base chain of the Y chromosome that are analyzed, one finds places where a short sequence of bases is repeated, e.g. GATA-GATA-GATA.
The number of repeats can change from generation to generation, and the analyses shown on the colored diagrams in FTDNA projects such as the Logan DNA Project, are matrices of the numbers of repeats at a certain segment (marker), for each participant along with the mode. Those that differs from the mode up or down are color coded.
The Lowland Lobban motif
To understand the motif, we first need to see that within the U198 project there is a set of haplogroups under DF89. The diagram below is a snippet from the FTDNA haplotree diagram. Within John Sloan’s U198 data set is a subset defined as “DF89+ but FGC12305 negative” which I have outlined in red on the diagram.
There are several markers that signal the Lobban motif but I first pick as an illustration one called DYS568 (chart below, extracted from the spreadsheet). Within this subset, most people have 11 repeats, that is the mode, but the minimum is 8 and maximum 12. [Indeed, scrolling through the chart for the entire R1b project, shows deviations from 11 in this marker are very few and very close — 10 or 12. (It’s the 53rd marker from the left of the chart.)] Yet, all of the Limb 7 (JFS0275) members have only 8 repeats, and there are two matches, both in JFS0266, who also have that number.
Some of the subset “DF89+ but negative for FGC12305” showing some of the participants and one of the STR markers, DYS568. Screenshot snippets assembled from U198 Project colorized chart, https://www.familytreedna.com/public/U198/default.aspx?section=ycolorized
FTDNA explains the color coding: “The Y-Chromosome DNA (Y-DNA) results chart is color coded to show where someone in a subgroup differs from the calculated modal value for an STR (short tandem repeat) marker. For each step less than the modal value, a progressively darker shade of blue is used for the background color. For each step greater than the modal value, a progressively darker shade of pink is used for the background color.” Thus the strong blue shading indicates a value much lower than the modal. (*Technical note at end.)
The spreadsheet screenshot below collects just the Limb 7 people, along with Holmes, Taffe and Bogard for comparison, and just the most important markers in the motif. DYS391 = 10; DYS449 = 30; DYS464 contains a 14; DYS456 = 14; DYS413 = 23, 24; DYS568 = 8.
This pattern can be also recognized in some matches to Limb 7 whose names are quite different. Updated results in the FTDNA tree show that this motif dates back before surnames, and that JFS0275 split before surnames into at least two groups, the Lowland Lobbans, now identified by a more specific marker, JFS0277, and a Holmes line that descends separately within the JFS0275 haplogroup. I have revised the Lowland Lobbans chart on the home page (Executive Summary) to show these changes and also updated the Status Report page and posted an updated Y-DNA Report.
A new level of ancestors and their descendant families
[Dec. 2021] What is really exciting to me about the motif, and the fact that the Holmes results have pushed JFS0275 back before surnames, is that the we now have a tool to explore another level of ancestry, the ancestors of our 1450AD MRCA, or at least the constellation of families among their descendants. There are other Limb 7 matches of interest — Hemphill, Scarborough, and Nash. The two Nashes now have a haplogroup in a branch at the level of JFS0275, under a new haplogroup JFS0279 as the common ancestor (see diagram below) but do not have the complete motif. I anticipate that the others will connect somewhere in this cluster over the Lowland Lobbans. Taafe, one step further back at JFS0282, has two differences from the Lobban motif, so it is probably not recognizable.
I see this cluster of families from our earlier ancestors as a higher taxonomic level (it would be called an Order in biological classification), visually like a banyan tree with a three-dimensional array of roots coming down from the starting point. These families do not include everyone with those names, of course. For example, Loban has two unrelated families and the Holmes donor has told me they have no matches to the English Holmes.
The data for the Lobban motif to Dec. 2022 stand as follows:
[Dec. 2022] We are now able to add approximate dates for the origins of the haplogroups back to about 250 A.D. and to trace the origins of some key components at the nodes along the way. The oldest and strongest is DYS568 = 8, which goes back to JFS0266 (diagram below). Next to change towards the motif were DYS456 = 14 at JFS082 and DYS391 = 10 at JFS0279. Finally, DYS413 = 23,24 completed the motif at JFS0275 about 1100 A.D. Also shown in the diagram below are that Nash and Scarborough both have DYS413 = 23,23; however, Scarborough differs only in that marker whereas Nash differs in one other marker, suggesting that there is additional structure between JFS0279 and JFS0275. Hemphill is indicated in a dashed ellipse because, although we see him in the STR data, we have no Y700 data yet.
The “banyan” tree is taking shape!
* Technical note: the values shown in each cell are absolute, but the coloring that FTDNA’s software does to show difference from the mode depends on the set for which the mode is calculated, in particular that the set contains a variety of samples. If the administrator made a set with only one close group, there would be almost no colorizing because all the individual values would be the modal value.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Page created by Christopher S. Lobban based on information from John Sloan and Jim Logan, posted 7 Nov. 2021, last revised 7 Jan. 2023.